Monday, November 25, 2019

Enter: The Master Of Black Magic!


When it comes to comic book stories, less can be so much more--and I know of no finer example of that time-tested idiom than a story premiering in mid-1963 which featured the first appearance of the Master of the Mystic Arts Black Magic, Dr. Strange, a tale which totaled a mere five pages but even in its simplicity managed not only to provide the reader with the basic elements of this intriguing new character's background but to also wrap those elements within a tidy yet satisfying first adventure. Written by Stan Lee with art by Steve Ditko, Strange made his debut as a backup feature in (what else?) Strange Tales, sporting a virtual marquee of his own.



The copy is quite correct (and perhaps intentional) in mentioning that the feature premieres quietly and without Marvel's usual cover fanfare; in fact, it would take seven issues (equating to seven months, which in a way underscores the point) before Strange would receive even a mention on the title's cover, as if Lee were walking on tiptoes with this character:



In his extensive section on Dr. Strange in Origins Of Marvel Comics, Lee makes no mention of his reticence in promoting the character--only that he and Ditko were "cautiously feeling [their] way" with him in terms of fleshing out the framework of his world and the extent of his abilities; yet it's really only a minor observation on my part, a matter of curiosity which some of the more learned among you may be able to shed some light on. In no way does it (nor should it) impact on what turns out to be a very nicely structured introduction to an intriguing character who, as the story's final panel announces, will be our guide to the mystic world which represents uncharted territory for those who until now have focused their efforts on super-heroes rooted in reality.

And as we'll see, even those in the real world have need for such a man.




Our catalyst, known in the story only as "the sleeper," is the means by which we're able to see how well this story proceeds in logical progression in order to acclimate the reader to this new character, his domicile, his limited supporting cast, and of course the story itself. How time indeed flies when you're having fun--five pages may well seem like ten (or more) to you by the time you've read it.

With Ditko having provided the essentials, Lee isn't negligent in exploring what he's been given, either through caption or dialog; and as the sleeper arrives at Strange's sanctum, it's delightful to turn these pages as if for the first time and let the words and descriptions guide us through what we're seeing. For instance, even in these early tales, Strange's manservant, the as yet unnamed Wong, has a high opinion of his master's knowledge and experience in the occult; and as if to back that up, we see that little if anything comes as a surprise to Strange or is otherwise unfamiliar to him. Visually, Ditko has also added that interesting patterning to Strange's gloves, and there's the ever-present incense to indicate he's contemplative and has adopted eastern methods of study. On a more cosmetic note, one can't help but do a double-take at the peculiar grooming of Strange's eyebrows and mustache.



Afterward, we get a sense that Strange has an idea of what he'll be encountering in this man's dream (and reading this story in hindsight, perhaps we're all on the same page with him in that respect)--so rather than have Strange look into the matter further, Lee and Ditko instead provide us with our introduction to the man from whom Strange acquired his knowledge and training--the Ancient One, though, like Wong, still unnamed at this point, perhaps to draw more focus to Strange as a principal character as well as conserve the limited story space available for exposition. Strange also demonstrates the use of his astral form--a variation of what we would see employed by Charles Xavier in the X-Men book to be launched two months after this story is published.



One thing Lee does make a point of establishing is that the Ancient One is unable to take on anything more than an advisory role in Strange's dealings with those he comes up against, though it will later become clear that the Ancient One's range in exercising that role is considerable.

With all that we need to become familiar with Strange taken care of, Ditko and Lee proceed directly to the mystery at hand, as our sleeper drifts off--with Strange again making use of his astral form to enter the dream of the dreamer. What he discovers is undoubtedly the sleeper's tormentor, who hints at the true reason for the dreamer's anguish; but the more dangerous culprit waits in the wings, a being whom Strange recognizes from past experience.




Yet in a nice twist to this bizarre story, it isn't Nightmare who may spell Strange's doom, but our awakening sleeper, who finally realizes why his dream has been recurring--only this time, his chained tormentor has uttered to Strange a name, one that the sleeper realizes Strange cannot be allowed to investigate.





Again, the introduction of a new piece of Strange's makeup as a sorcerer that will come to be something more--the Eye of Agamotto, here only the unnamed, vaguely defined power within Strange's amulet (destined to be traded in for a newer one at a later date), which foils the sleeper's intent as well as, indirectly, Nightmare's. And with the return of Strange's astral form comes the answer at last.



It's of course a story that, with the removal of Strange and Nightmare and the addition of two or three more pages, would have fit well in the earlier issues of Strange Tales that had only ordinary humans to deal with such eerie situations. (In fact I wouldn't be surprised if this tale had recycled such a story.)

We've seen here merely a glimpse of what Strange has to offer, his "black magic" manifested in really only two ways that the reader can base their interest--his "metaphysical" form and his "magic amulet," the latter of which unfortunately appears to be his ultimate weapon in a crunch (and so visually distinctive as to let any attacker know it's the one thing to immediately neutralize):



Yet all in all, a fine step forward for a new and very different character who would be tapped to join Marvel's ranks in the early '60s--as well as a character who would add a great deal to Ditko's reputation as a noteworthy artist and storyteller.

NEXT:
The debut of... who else? ... Baron Mordo!


Strange Tales #110

Script: Stan Lee
Pencils and Inks: Steve Ditko
Letterer: Terry Szenics

10 comments:

Kid said...

Actually, the amulet on display here IS the later one he was given, as subsequent tales appear to take place before this one (at least the ones after his origin do). This leads to an interesting anomaly, as Strange was clearly drawn as an Oriental in the early stories, but this was eventually changed to make him a Caucasian.

As for Wong and the Ancient one not yet being named, I think that's more likely to be a case of Stan and Steve feeling their way as they go along and not yet having worked out the details of any supporting cast, rather than save story space on exposition.

This is a recoloured version by Andy Yanchus, and although I'm usually more archival-minded when it comes to reprints, I have to say that it's more atmospheric than the original colouring. It's nice when you can have both versions though.

Comicsfan said...

Kid, I think we can settle the issue of the amulet by taking a look at the story (linked above) where Strange proves himself against Dormammu and receives some new accessories for his trouble, which include "a more wondrous" amulet (which may be the one he's wearing when the Avengers storm his sanctum, by the look of it). Maybe the less wondrous amulet will one day show up at a flea market somewhere--I'm hoping I can pick it up for a buck fifty. :D

Anonymous said...

Those early Dr. Strange stories have become classics while the Human Torch stories which featured on the covers of Strange Tales have been long forgotten.

Big Murr said...

That is a brilliant short piece of fiction!

I imagine Lee and Dikto were "cautiously feeling their way" if only because this sort of story was right in the neighbourhood of the tales that created the mass hysteria among parents and created the Comics Code Authority. Had to walk the line and not drift from "spooky" to "horror".

Stan didn't strain his brain too hard when he slapped "black magic" on the label. When has "black magic" ever been used except in a dark, villainous context?? How long did it take for "mystic arts" to appear?

Kid said...

Yes, CF, but the first three tales are meant to have taken place after Strange was presented with his new amulet, so the stories are out of historical sequence (though not published sequence), which is why he refers to Nightmare as his 'ancient foe' - that first tale actually appears somewhere down the line.

From his origin tale on (until that Dormammu story you refer to), his amulet is a square-ish shape, and when he's 'officially' presented with his new amulet, it's pretty much the same one as in his first three adventures, though just ever-so-slightly less ornate. It's meant to be the same amulet that Strange had in his first appearance, but obviously Ditko has simplified it slightly for ease of drawing.

So, to recap, from his origin to receiving his new amulet, the tales take place at the start of his mystic 'career', but the first three tales are from later in his career, and occur after he got his new amulet. Check it out and you'll see I'm right. If Nightmare is his 'ancient foe' in his very first story, then that very first story (and the following two, 'cos he's wearing the same new amulet) didn't take place at the start of him becoming 'master of the mystic arts'.

In short, Stan & Steve dropped us right into the middle of Strange's mystic life, not the beginning (until the origin).

Kid said...

Or maybe that's what you were saying anyway, but I was just too dense (it happens somedays) to pick up on it.

Tiboldt said...

Doctor Strange Trivia point 1: Steve Ditko drew Steven Strange to look like Vincent Price, which is why his middle name is Vincent.

Not even the Beast would call him Vinny though.

Doctor Strange Trivia point 2: He was not lead singer with 80's synthpop band Visage.

Comicsfan said...

Kid, I'm glad you make the point of mentioning the indications we're given in this story that Strange has been in operation for quite awhile. With Strange an unknown quantity in these beginning tales, it's possible that Stan arranged that intentionally so as not to have to bring the reader up to speed with the character and instead have him get right to the action as a viable sorcerer already adept in the occult.

I have some doubt as to the timeline you're proposing, however; for instance, following the Dormammu story, I get no sense that we're seeing Strange at the beginning of his mystic career. For one thing, it would mean that Strange was returning from the Dark Dimension having successfully faced one of the most powerful sorcerous forces in existence as little more than an untried novice; but also, in the following story, his foe indicates he's been in hiding for years so that he could become stronger than Strange and thus be certain to defeat him. But we can also try looking at this from a more common-sense perspective: With the new amulet, Strange also receives his new cloak of levitation, yes? And yet if we stick to the theory that Strange was sporting his new amulet in his debut appearance, that would mean that for whatever reason he had decided to avoid donning the new cloak, choosing instead to stick to his original garb. What reason would he have for doing that?

If I were bucking for a no-prize, I might try explaining that away as (a) an overwhelming attachment to his darker cloak; or maybe (b) he needed time to adjust to the Ancient One's odd sense of fashion; or (c) perhaps the new cloak made him stand out more in a crowd; or how about (d) the new cloak was too darn heavy and he needed to increase his workouts with Wong to wear it comfortably. To be honest, I don't really think that Stan gave any of this an ounce of serious thought, given that his priority in those early tales was likely to introduce us to a confident, capable character who was practiced in dealing with forces beyond our comprehension, someone we would be curious about and interested in from Day One. It was really only Strange's origin tale which established any sort of history for Strange, while leaving how long he'd spent in the Ancient One's service until that point to our imagination.

In any event, I enjoyed our discussion quite a lot. :)

Murray, that's not a bad notion about the Comics Code aspect--though surely I'd expect the phrase "black magic" wielded by a hero and not a villain to raise a few eyebrows in the CCA office.

Colin, those Torch/Thing stories were a little off the grid as far as aligning with the FF mag, albeit loosely so--but perhaps they served to simply coax non-FF readers to the team's main mag. Those stories are one of my guilty pleasures, I admit--absurd in places, but all in good fun.

Tiboldt, that was certainly a heck of a stage name for Mr. Strange--did he ever elaborate on it?

Anonymous said...

Great post. This was really basically a supernatural tale with an interesting twist--a superhero-like character. Well, sort of. But it worked so Stan ran with it. Looking forward to Mordo's debut. I'm not sure I've seen that one.
Y'know, I had no idea the Eel went back that far. I remember him primarily as one of the goon squad in Englehart's Captain America, along with the Porcupine, Scarecrow, and, uh, Jughead and Snuffie Smith and uh... whatsisname.

M.P.

Kid said...

I'd say that by the time Strange encountered Dormammu, because there's no definite timeline, then it obviously comes further along in the 'start' of his career than when his origin tale occurred, but is still relatively close to when he 'graduated' as a sorcerer. However, remember that his origin ends with the words "The days turned to weeks, to months, to years", so he was hardly a novice when he faced Dormammu for the first time, he was a practiced sorcerer with many years of study under his belt before he 'graduated'. I merely meant that the first three tales came after his encounter with Dormammu.

As for the cape, I'd noticed the difference, but merely assumed that Ditko was taking a little artistic license to update Strange's appearance. Strange doesn't wear a cape in his first two stories, so it was a 'development' as Stan and Steve went along. The amulet given to him is very like the one first shown in his debut, though George Roussos simplifies it with his inking in the third tale. One thing's for sure - if Nightmare is Strange's ancient foe, then he's encountered him before a good while back.

Of course, it could just be that Ditko changed the amulet in the fourth tale (the origin) because it was perhaps simpler to draw, and then switched it back again when he decided he preferred the original one. (Or maybe Stan asked him to.) However, Steve usually had a reason for doing things and seldom seemed to act on a whim, so that's why I favour the idea that the 'new' amulet was the same one as in the debut tale, although that doesn't cover the new cape - or Strange's changing 'racial' characteristics.

However, I don't suppose either of us can rely too much on anything to support our theories in regard to what was a 'work in progress', especially (to reiterate) as Strange is clearly Oriental in his early tales, but then changes to Caucasian. If my way of looking at things is justified, it actually happened in reverse, with him starting out as a 'white man', then becoming an Oriental, then changing back again. As I said, Stan and Steve were making it all up as they went along, so there are bound to be a few inconsistencies.

Enjoyed the chat.